CRITICISM IN A POST-RACIAL SOCIETY
This bothered me. An event in mid-2025 blew through, like a chubasco, the fast moving, violent Pacific storm, that vanishes as fast as it appears.
The teapot for the tempest was the digital Film Media, a passionate band of cinema-lovers, critics, pundits, podcasters, prognosticators and bloggers. These news sites love to debate every aspect of cinema.
In 2025, "Sinners," a film by talented director Ryan Coogler was released. I even went to see the Jim Crow South period piece in a movie theatre; Art Report Today covered the production extensively.
The film was full of talent. Thespians Michael B. Jordan, Hailee Steinfeld and Jack O'Connell lead an amazing cast. Score was composed by Ludwig Göransson. Coogler is a highly-accomplished and creative filmmaker. (Fruitvale Station, Creed, two Black Panther blockbusters).
"Sinners" is a mess of very beautiful intentions.
The Film Media began to review it. Not everyone felt the film was nothing less than a Cinematic Miracle. One said that "the cinematography may be a bit dim." Another stated that "the screenwriting might possibly miss several opportunities."
Suddenly, like a crash of Olympus thunder, a violent and very loud gaggle of Harpies descended upon the unenlightened film critics, furiously pecking at their flesh with cries of "Racist Hate Monger!"
Issues with the mise en scène? "Racist!" This deafening social media barrage was all Shock & Awe. Flatly stunned, the Film Media stood silent, gaping for words. No one bothered to mention "Sinners" again. Untouched, the mainstream entertainment media never spoke of it.
This weird kerfuffle nettled me.
Movie criticism was our last universal Safe Space.
Race has blatantly entered the world of criticism. And that never works out beautifully. This kind of thing would not exist in a Post-Racial society.
Now, with the Best Picture oddsmakers throwing their dice, "Sinners" is on a few, not all, racing forms. Like a chubasco, the Harpies are attacking Rolling Stone for their 'racist' exclusion of the film from their Best Of.
I will take leave and let the great film journo Jordan Ruimy explain the new assault. Click Here to read his "‘Sinners' Left Off Rolling Stone’s Top 20 of 2025 — Hive Mind Meltdown Ensues."
Art Report Today .com